CPR compression rotation every one minute versus two minutes: A
randomized cross-over manikin study
Abstract
Background: Current basic life support guidelines recommend two-minute
shifts for providing chest compressions when two rescuers are performing
cardiopulmonary resuscitation. However, various studies have found that
rescuer fatigue can occur within one minute, coupled with a decay in the
quality of chest compressions. Our aim was to compare chest compression
quality metrics and rescuer fatigue between alternating rescuers in
performing one and two-minute chest compressions. Methods: This
prospective randomized cross-over study was conducted at Songklanagarind
hospital, Hat Yai, Songkhla, Thailand. We enrolled sixth-year medical
students and residents and randomly grouped them into pairs to perform 8
minutes of chest compression, utilizing both the one-minute and
two-minute scenarios on a manikin. The primary end-points were chest
compression depth and rate. The secondary end-points included rescuers’
fatigue, respiratory rate, and heart rate. Results: One-hundred and four
participants were recruited. Compared with participants in the
two-minute group, participants in the one-minute group had significantly
higher mean (standard deviation, SD) compression depth [mm] (45.8
(7.2) vs 44.5 (7.1), P=0.01) but there was no difference in the mean
(SD) rate [compressions per min] (116.1 (12.5) vs 117.8 (12.4), p =
0.08), respectively. The rescuers in the one-minute group had
significantly less fatigue (P<0.001) and changes in
respiratory rate (P<0.001), but there was no difference in the
change of heart rate (P=0.59) between the two groups. Conclusion: There
was significantly higher compression depth and lower rescuer fatigue in
the 1-minute chest compression group compared with the 2-minute group.
(Thai Clinical Trials Registry TCTR20170823001)