General Comments
and Feedback
Number of Hours Spent
to Review the Report:
Quality of the Report (DROPDOWN MENU):
Superior, Good,
Fair, Poor
Rate the importance of this report to
clinical practice and research and
usability in the following categories:
1. Contribution to the Existing Literature (1 high
importance/level of contribution, 2 moderate importance/level of contribution, 3
minor importance/level of contribution, 4 not important/minor contribution)
Comments:__________________
2. Scientific Validity (1 valid, 2 largely valid,
but needs some clarification or revision, 3 not valid)
Comments: ____________________
3. Clarity (1 clear and understandable, 2 largely clear,
but needs some clarifications or revision, 3 unclear)
Comments: _________________________
[USEFUL TO
ASK HOW THE REPORT COULD BE MADE MORE USEFUL TO GENERAL PUBLIC/CONSUMERS? OR
NON-SPECIALISTS?]
4. Copyediting (1 minimal errors 2 moderate errors
3 requires close editing)
Comments:
________________________
[ADD
READABILITY ALSO?? THIS MAY OPEN UP SOME PROGRAMMATIC CHANGES??? E.G., OVERALL
READABILITY (SCALE OF x-x), USE OF ACRONYMS (APPROPRIATE, INAPPROPRIATE),
LANGUAGE]
5. Abstract: Does the abstract appropriately
summarize the report without omitting important results or inappropriately
reporting findings: Yes/No Comment: ____________________________
[USEFUL TO
HAVE A QUESTION HERE (OR MAYBE AS A SUPPLEMENTARY PIECE THAT REVIEWERS CAN
ELECT TO COMPLETE) TO HELP THE PROGRAM IN PLANNING OR THE EC IN CREATING USER
PRODUCTS? SOMETHING LIKE, WHAT ARE THE KEY MESSAGES FOR STAKEHOLDERS? ]
Specific Comments and Feedback
Report Section
| Points to Consider in Your Review
| Your Comment
| PDF Line #
| Importance of Comment Major (requires
significant revision to clarify/correct;
authors will provide thorough
response)
Minor (requires
minimal or no revision;
does not affect report significantly and
may not be
addressed in detail by the report authors)
Copyediting/Linguistic
(issues with grammar, word choice, spelling)
|
[these would be rows in the table, but for ease in editing, I did not make them rows]
Executive Summary
Introduction
Methods
Results
Discussion: General
Discussion: Future Reserach
Discussion: Clinical Implications
Discussion: Limitations
Conclusions
General Comments