The novelty of MtZIP6 is a notable finding and gives exciting justification to characterize the protein. Overall the paper and its findings were easily understood, even of nonexperts. 

As the aim of the PREreview Journal Club is to support the authors by providing constructive feedback, the reviewer(s) should also include positive remarks to encourage future posting of preprints. Remember, the authors are human too! To help guide you, here are a few questions you might ask yourself after reading the preprint: