Experimental design
The common garden experiment has been described at greater length
elsewhere (Vojtech et al., 2008,
Vojtech et al., 2007,
HautierVojtech et al., 2018). Briefly, we
established monocultures (n=5), all pairwise mixtures (n=10) and the
full five-species mixtures (n=1) of five perennial grass species
(Poaceae): Alopecurus pratensis L., Anthoxanthum odoratumL., Arrhenatherum elatius (L.) P. Beauv. ex J. Presl & C. Presl,Festuca rubra ssp. commutata Gaud. (= Festuca
nigrescens Lam.), Holcus lanatus L.
(Lauber and Wagner, 2001). Each species
combination was replicated five times for a total of 80 plots. Species
were sown at a target density of 1000 seeds m-2 from
seeds of individual species. Plants were established in 1
m2 plots on highly fertile soil (Garden humus,
Ricoter, Aarberg, Switzerland). The experiment ran from April 2004 to
June 2008. Plots were watered daily and regularly weeded throughout the
duration of the experiment. During 2005 and 2006, plants were regularly
fertilized with an NPK fertilizer corresponding to 15 g
m-2 yr-1 of nitrogen to create
highly productive conditions. In 2007, we divided the plots into four
subplots of 50 x 50 cm (Fig. S1). In half of these subplots, we
maintained the initial highly productive conditions by continuously
adding the NPK fertilizer. In the other half of the subplots we reduced
soil fertility by a combination of the cessation of fertilization and
the addition of sucrose (in five applications of 500 g
m-2 year-1 during 2007 and two
applications of 625 g m-2 in 2008). Addition of a
carbon source limits nutrient availability to plants and reduces
productivity due to the immobilisation of nitrogen by soil
micro-organisms (Killham, 1994) and increases competition between
micro-organisms and plants for nitrate and ammonium (Bardgett et al.,
2003; Schmidt et al., 1997). Additionally, we crossed the productivity
treatments with regular cutting of the canopy structure to create
disturbed conditions (HautierVojtech et
al., 2018). Calculating daily RGR per species throughout the growing
season for the plots that were disturbed was not possible because of the
limited number of samples between each cutting event. Here, we therefore
analyse only the undisturbed productive and unproductive conditions.