Letter - Hypothesis
As for June, 25, 2020, more than 9.5 million cases and almost 4.8
hundred thousand deaths were officially recorded worldwide. One of the
most deadly clinical features of this devastating infection is the so
called “cytokine storm”, the uncontrolled surge in cytokines that, at
a first moment is intended to fight the infection but, once out of
control, starts to offend the organs and tissues of the host.
Particularly in SARS-COV-2 infection, such cytokine storm has been
observed after the acute infection leading to re-hospitalization with a
less positive outcome. Therefore, therapeutics targeted to fight this
late immune reaction of the organism may be of great benefit and life
saving (Cardone et al. , 2020). In
addition, most of the high throughput screening campaigns to repurpose
current use drugs has focused on the anti-viral properties while the
anti-cytokine-storm properties cannot be addressed in high throughput. A
recent development on the therapeutic front is the demonstration that
Dexamethasone can reduce the mortality rate among severe cases of
COVID-19 (see https://www.recoverytrial.net/). The use of a
corticosteroid to treat infectious conditions has been considered with
caution given the immunosuppressive side effect of this class of drugs.
Therefore, alternatives should always be considered. In this line, a
recent paper published in late 2019, in Science Translational Medicine
may bring a new alternative involving a commonly used antidepressant
drug in a new function: Fluvoxamine (Rosenet al. , 2019).
One of the key modulators of cytokine secretion is the Sigma-1 receptor,
an intracellular receptor with elusive and multiple functions, found in
the endoplasmic reticulum of many cell types including neurons and
immune cells (Schmidt et al. ,
2019). Sigma-1 receptor was initially classified as opioid receptor sigma-1 but no
consistent interactions with real opioids were found, so now they are
better described as Sigma non-opioid intracellular receptor 1 (See
IUPHAR Guide to Pharmacology). It is still considered an orphan receptor
as far as an endogenous ligand is not recognized. As nicely
reviewed by (Schmidtet al. , 2019), this receptor interacts with at least 49 proteins
in several different ways from GPCR to ion channels and is considered a
ligand-operated chaperone. What makes this mysterious intracellular
receptor particularly interesting is that one of the COVID-19 proteins
showed affinity for this receptor: Nsp6
(Gordon et al. , 2020). The function
of Nsp6 protein is related to endoplasmic reticulum remodeling to favor
Coronavirus replication. The authors above screened several Sigma1
receptor ligands for viral infectivity and/or replication and concluded
that most of the antagonists had little or no effect. All the drugs
tested though, were essentially antagonists of this receptor, and the
aim was finding a blocking agent. The only agonist tested was
dextromethorphane which presented an increase in viral titers in vitro.
On the other hand, cloperastine and clemastine showed good antiviral
properties and affinity for both Sigma-1 and Sigma-2 receptors but
importantly, these drugs were not experimentally classified as
antagonists or agonists of Sigma receptors. The authors performed a
docking modeling against Sigma-1 receptor structure and observed a good
fit. Clearly, the goal of this study was to identify drugs that might be
repurposed to fight the SARS-COV-2 infection and replication. The question whether these drugs can control the cytokine storm, the most
dangerous outcome of this infection, after pneumonia, is in focus now.
In this respect a study by Rosen and
colleagues(Rosen et al. , 2019)
published in 2019 discovered the interplay between Sigma-1 receptors and
the Inositol-Requiring Enzime 1-alpha (IRE1), an ER stress sensor. They
demonstrated that both proteins are in close proximity and possibly
interact. As cited by these authors, IRE1 is a potent cytokine regulator
and can be activated by lipopolysacharide (LPS). They demonstrated that Sigma-1 receptors interact with IRE1 to produce hyper
inflammation under the appropriate stimulation in vitro and in vivo. Also used human bone marrow derived mastocytes (BMDM)
normal and KO for Sigma-1 receptors, reinforcing the translational
potential of the study. The authors used a Sigma-1 receptor ligand that
may represent a hope in the treatment of the cytokine storm, namely
Fluvoxamine. This drug has low nanomolar affinity for Sigma-1 receptors
with reported anti-inflammatory effects
(Ghareghani et al. , 2017).
Fluvoxamine stimulated Sigma-1 receptors and effectively dampened the
secretion of cytokines, increased survival rates in two in vivo models of sepsis, LPS and fecal-induced peritonitis.
As for the present state of the knowledge on the molecular mechanisms
underlying the triggering of the cytokine storm, the description of one
SARS-COV-2 protein with affinity for Sigma-1 receptor, which by its turn
is a critical player in controlling IRE1 nuclease activity, responsible
for starting the cytokine storm, may be a good clue to reach an
efficient control of this devastating condition. In this respect,
fluvoxamine may represent an alternative but may not be the only one.
Other Sigma-1 agonists have been reported and among them clemastine,
cloperastine and dextromethorphan, all readily available and in clinical
use. Dextromethorphae have to be taken with caution since it may increase
viral titters, as cited above but in low dose it has important
protective effects in sepsis and may still be considered
(Zhou et al. , 2019). Others like
the PRE-084, SKF10-047 should be considered as potential game changers
in the fight against this unprecedented pandemic. A careful evaluation of the
evolution of infection should be made in order to make timely treatment
with these potentially life saving drugs.
Cardone M, Yano M, Rosenberg AS, Puig
M (2020). Lessons Learned to Date on COVID-19 Hyperinflammatory
Syndrome: Considerations for Interventions to Mitigate SARS-CoV-2 Viral
Infection and Detrimental Hyperinflammation. Frontiers in
Immunology 11 (1131).
Ghareghani M, Zibara K, Sadeghi H,
Dokoohaki S, Aryanpour R, Ghanbari A (2017). Fluvoxamine stimulates
oligodendrogenesis of cultured neural stem cells and attenuates
inflammation and demyelination in an animal model of multiple sclerosis.Sci Rep 7 (1): 4923.
Gordon DE, Jang GM, Bouhaddou M, Xu J,
Obernier K, White KM, et al. (2020). A SARS-CoV-2 protein
interaction map reveals targets for drug repurposing. Nature .
Rosen DA, Seki SM, Fernandez-Castaneda
A, Beiter RM, Eccles JD, Woodfolk JA, et al. (2019). Modulation
of the sigma-1 receptor-IRE1 pathway is beneficial in preclinical models
of inflammation and sepsis. Sci Transl Med 11 (478).
Schmidt HR, Kruse AC (2019). The
Molecular Function of σ Receptors: Past, Present, and Future.Trends Pharmacol. Sci. 40 (9): 636-654.
Zhou R, Chen S-H, Li G, Chen H-L, Liu
Y, Wu H-M, et al. (2019). Ultralow doses of dextromethorphan
protect mice from endotoxin-induced sepsis-like hepatotoxicity.Chem.-Biol. Interact. 303: 50-56.