Introduction
The COVID-19 pandemic gave birth to an unexpected situation worldwide.
Though some were well prepared, lockdown measures in France have had a
major impact on patients’ mental health, whether they already had a
psychiatric history or not.
While other authors have reported psychiatric decompensating due to
COVID-19 confinement measures1,2, we have not yet not
thought much about elderly patients, particularly those who lived in
occupied France between 1939 and 1945.
Here, we present the case of a patient with reactivated war memories
during the COVID-19 lockdown period, presenting with a rheumatoid
arthritis flare after disease control without any drugs since 2015.
Case history
Ms. F., an 80-year-old woman, came to the office on April
14th. She presented with joint stiffness, finger and
hip articular pain, and notable asthenia. At the beginning of May, she
then started to have a fever of approximately 38°C. On examination, her
vitals were as follows: heart rate 100 beats per minute and blood
pressure 130/70 mmHg. Her pain prevented her from sleeping, her asthenia
persisted, and her CRP was elevated. Given the situation, we decided to
treat her with prednisolone and send her to her referring
rheumatologist. The latter confirmed that she was having a rheumatoid
arthritis flare and prescribed corticoids until September.
This woman was known to have rheumatoid arthritis since 2012, when she
had her first flare. At this time, her rheumatologist introduced
cortisone and methotrexate. In 2015, she was stable under this therapy,
and her treatment was stopped. Since 2015, she has had no symptoms at
all of her condition, without any medication.
No potential organic cause of this arthritis flare has been found.
However, when speaking din depth with the patient, she told us
interesting details about her feelings regarding the lockdown measures.
As a matter of fact, she retrospectively noticed that, from March
16th to May 11th, her feelings were
“anesthetized”, and the confinement measures reminded her of her World
War Two (WWII) habits.
Ms. F. grew up in a village under German occupation during WWII. At the
consultation, she expressed she felt like she has had a growing “fear
of the Germans” every day. During the COVID-19 lockdown period, her
papers were controlled each time she left her house. In particular, she
was controlled when she went to the next village to tend to some errands
that could not be done in her village, which reminded her of the “open
cities” during WWII.
Additionally, she did not at all expect the lockdown measures. Getting
back from holiday, she turned on TV and heard “this is war ”.
Her son came immediately, telling her that he was “not sure when
we will see each other again ”. Her daughter came the next day to say
goodbye too. Ms. F. was an active person in her village, but all of her
social activities were stopped.
Investigations
As soon as she verbalized the memories coming back from WWII, we looked
for potential posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) using the
Posttraumatic Stress Disorder Checklist Scale (PCL 5), DSM-5 version. We
did not find significant PTSD; her total score of 17 (from 0 to 80),
with most of the points concerned with three criteria: “Loss of
interest in activities that you used to enjoy”, “Feeling distant or
cut off from other people”, and “Trouble experiencing positive
feelings (for example, being unable to feel happiness or have loving
feelings for people close to you)”.
A total score between 31 and 33 suggests probable
PTSD3; in this case, the lack of avoidance, intrusive
symptoms and hyperarousal forces us to believe there was no PTSD for
this patient. Hence, a provisional PTSD diagnosis could not be
made because there were no moderate or higher symptoms apart from
cluster D symptoms, which represent negative symptoms for PTSD according
to the DSM-5.
However, Ms. F. had previously reported real flashbacks before the
COVID-19 pandemic. She relived German interrogation while being at a
friend’s doctor appointment. She was accompanying her but did not know
why her friend needed her. During the appointment, her friend related
private information, and Ms. F. had an intrusive symptom, felling like
she was reliving a German interrogatory. She froze and could not move
from her chair anymore. According to her, the health professionals who
were there had to stimulate her until she came out of this flashback and
could move again.
We did not interrogate Ms. F. about a potential PTSD diagnosis before
the lockdown period. If her score was down to zero before COVID-19, we
would think that this period had a real impact on her psychological
quality of life. Additionally, elderly patients can have very
nonspecific symptoms4.
Discussion
This case is an interesting one to think about mental health prevention
in elderly patients’ during unexpected major events. Indeed, older
patients have a past that practitioners did not live, such as having
experienced World War Two. We may forget about these events, but they
still have an impact on elderly people’s quality of life and health.
Different studies have found a significant impact of WWII on both mental
disorder prevalence and physical morbidity5,.
Additionally, past trauma can create delayed and nonclassical symptoms
in the elderly4. In this precise case, even though we
could not find any link between the patient’s rheumatologic conditions
and her past resurgence during lockdown, we imagine that any
psychological support would likely have been appreciated. Indeed, asking
about patients’ feelings and past experiences during such unique
conditions may help them express their feelings, and they may ask for
psychological help. In the particular case of COVID-19 lockdown, a
patient who may have been thinking the whole time that the lockdown
measures were “an order” could have been reassured if a healthcare
professional could explain than those measures were national health
measures rather than real war conditions.