Maughan, Sandhu 2020
|
Departmental series
Prospective
|
141/150
|
48
(18-86)
|
All SL benign cases
|
Dedo-Pilling (+/- Lindholm)
|
16min (range 2-61min)
|
66%
|
6.7%
|
3%
|
1.3%
|
|
|
All by end of second POW
|
|
Okui, Watanabe 2019
|
Departmental record review
Retrospective
|
550/-
|
43.9
(28-60)
|
All MLS benign cases
|
Nagashima (small or very small)
|
11min (+/-14mins)
|
40%
|
22.8%
|
12%
|
4.9%
|
1 anaphylactic shock to Suggamadex
|
1 VC oedema, 1 bleeding, 13.4% cough, 2% neck pain
|
All resolved, most in 4 days, 16.7% tongue Sx took >POW3
to resolve.
|
|
Larner, Griffith 2019
|
Departmental series
Retrospective
|
174/213
|
58.5
(24-89)
|
Benign & malignant SL cases
|
Ossoff-Pilling, Dedo-Pilling, Zeitelsf #4
|
Not reported (but 2/213 >30mins)
|
43%
|
1.2%
|
0.2%
|
0.5%
|
|
1 gum ulceration, 1 nasal tip laser burn
|
Not reported
|
3min breaks between 30min continuous SL periods. All tongue Sx occurred
with Lewy system
|
Ozdamar, Celik 2019
|
Single surgeon series
Prospective
Blinded f/u
|
56/56
|
47.7 (19-84)
|
All benign & malignant SL cases
|
Kleinsasser (small, medium or large)
|
26mins (range 20-45min)
|
Not reported
|
8.9%
|
-
|
-
|
|
|
3 Sx (2 mild numbness,1 ?what) resolved in POW1, 2 ?what resolved in
POM1
|
|
Feng, Song 2018
|
Experimental cohort
Prospective
Blinded
|
56/-
|
58 (19-83)
|
SL cases recruited in clinic, majority benign
|
Size 6 universal modular glottiscope
|
34min (SD 7-18mins)
|
Not reported
|
53.5%
|
-
|
-
|
|
|
Not reported
|
Max force/Avg force/total impulse correlated with tongue Sx &
odynophagia. Women 30% more tongue Sx
|
Tessema, Sessions 2016
|
Single surgeon series
Retrospective
|
122/100
|
46 (14-83)
|
All SL therapeutic cases
|
Dedo-Pilling (+/- Lindholm)
|
43.6min. 19% >60mins duration
|
Not reported
|
18%
|
-
|
4.0%
|
|
|
14 resolved at POM1, 3 resolved at POM3, 1 residual dysguesia
|
Lewy suspension system used
|
Dos Anjos Corvo, Campos Duprat 2007
|
Departmental series
Prospective
|
36/37
|
48 (18-80)
|
All SL benign or malignant suspicion cases
|
Holinger or Kleinsasser
|
14 <30min, 16 30-60mins, 7 >60mins
|
Not reported
|
13.5%
|
130%
|
2.7%
|
|
|
All tongues ’improved’ by end of POM2
|
Oral cavity exam pre-op incl teeth, taste & sensation grossly
tested
|
Rosen, Buckmire 2005
|
Departmental series
Prospective
|
53/56
|
50
|
All SL benign cases
|
Size 4,5 or 6 universal modular glottiscope
|
52mins (range 5-142mins)
|
Not reported
|
17.9%
|
-
|
12.5%
|
|
3 dry mouths
|
Avg POD11, longest POD34
|
Boston suspension system used. 9 patients had >1 symptom.
Largest scope UMG-6 caused 86% complications & of longer
duration
|
Klussman, Eckel 2002
|
Departmental series
Prospective
|
339/-
|
59 (29-86)
|
All planned SL benign & malignant cases, 82% intubated
|
Not specified
|
Not reported
|
Not reported
|
3.8%
|
105%
|
6.5%
|
|
|
Lingual POW1-60 (median 4), hypoglossal POW6-16 (median 8)
|
Mucosal lesions 20% higher in intubated patients. 40% dental injuries
were lower jaw. Vast majority had pre-op peridontal disease
|